Stacy attempts to reconnect with her ex best friend Andrea, and her tragic past is revealed. Todd gets angry when Louis and Reid seem to bond especially well, and Anya finally learns the whereabouts of Joe Biden (her pet lizard).
As tension builds between the group, Anya takes it into her own hands to stop the fighting. The party comes to a sudden halt and the gang says goodbye to each other for the final time as college students.
Gavin goes on a hunt for the mischievous freshman who snuck into the party, and remembers his various failures as a non-varsity athlete. Gavin’s mysterious girlfriend Ingrid, finally makes an appearance.
Todd tries to figure out what his life is going to look like after college. Anya gets out the karaoke machine and chaos ensues.
Reid struggles to get the closure that she wants with Todd, and remembers the various ups and downs of their relationship. Stacy is upset when she finds out Anya invited her nemesis to the party.
The crew waits for their party guests to arrive however a few of them aren’t welcome. Louis remembers all the times his friends have taken advantage of him, despite the fact that this party is supposed to be for his birthday.